Natalie M. McMahan is an attorney who represents individuals and both privately held and public companies in a wide range of civil litigation matters. Natalie’s practice focuses on representing insurance companies in coverage and liability disputes, including extracontractual defense. She also represents financial institutions in commercial litigation and defends employers in wage, labor, contract, and discrimination lawsuits. Natalie has represented clients through administrative proceedings and all stages of litigation in state and federal courts. Natalie also regularly assists clients with estate planning, trust administration, and probate matters.

Natalie attended the University of Oklahoma College of Law where she earned the American Jurisprudence Award for Professional Responsibility, Litigation Skills, and the Criminal Defense Clinic. She served as the Staff Editor on the Oklahoma Law Review and was on the Dean’s Honor Roll.

Prior to law school, Natalie was an Officer in the U.S. Navy. She now lives in Edmond with her husband and their daughter.

• University of Oklahoma (B.A., 2012)
• University of Oklahoma College of Law (J.D., 2020)

• Oklahoma County Bar Association (Member, Young Lawyers Division Board of Directors, 2021)
• Oklahoma Bar Association

• Represented parties in disputes involving insurance coverage, breach of insurance contracts and bad faith
• Rendered coverage opinions for large loss claims against first party insurance policies
• Defended small and large businesses against claims of discrimination and wage violations
• Rendered advice to individuals and entities regarding the Oklahoma Ethics Rules for political campaigns

• Super Lawyers Rising Star (2024-present)
• Best Lawyers® in America: Ones to Watch (2022-present)
• 405 Magazine Top Attorney in Insurance (2025)
• 405 Magazine Top Attorney in Commercial Litigation (2023-2024)